The beauty world has been buzzing with viral mascaras, and of course, curiosity calls for putting them to the test.

While some hyped products fall short, every now and then, a true gem emerges. Today, two drugstore favorites go head-to-head to see which one really takes the crown!

1. L'Oréal Telescopic Lift Waterproof Mascara

Brush Type: Silicone brush with hooked bristles

This mascara is all about length, lift, and volume. The unique brush design grabs onto lashes, coating them evenly for a dramatic effect. It's also smudge-resistant, flake-free, and stays put all day, making it a reliable option for long wear.

2. Maybelline Surreal Waterproof Mascara

Brush Type: Plastic spoolie-style brush

Designed to lengthen and lift, this formula gives lashes a clean, extended look. Just like its rival, it's built to last without smudging or flaking. Its lightweight finish makes it perfect for those who want definition without too much volume.

Whether you're team length or team volume, these two mascaras prove why they've gone viral. Affordable, effective, and long-lasting, they're both worthy additions to your makeup bag—though L'Oréal takes the spotlight for those who crave a bolder lash look!