Finishing up beauty products always feels satisfying, but it also offers a perfect moment to reflect—were they worth the hype, and would they make it back into the routine?

After finishing a few skincare favorites, here’s a breakdown of what impressed, what fell short, and what’s truly worth buying again!

1. Tatcha The Clarifying Clay Mask Exfoliating Pore Treatment

This mask stands out for its unique texture and color-changing formula. It starts as a sage green and transforms into a soft red as you massage it into your skin. The exfoliating grit is gentle yet effective, leaving the skin feeling smooth and refreshed without any dryness. While it helps to enhance glow and clarity, it doesn’t quite deliver dramatic results for pore size or deep congestion. Still, the gentle tightening effect and overall radiance it brings are undeniable.

2. Caudalie Vinoperfect Radiance Dark Spot Serum

This serum targets dark spots, dullness, and uneven texture using a Vitamin C alternative. The texture feels light, hydrating, and absorbs beautifully into the skin without leaving a greasy film. It gives a lovely glow and a plump finish after each use. However, when it comes to fading dark spots or improving uneven skin tone, the results were minimal. For the price, there may be more affordable options that deliver similar outcomes.

3. Dr. Dennis Gross Advanced Retinol + Ferulic Triple Correction Eye Serum

This one truly lives up to its reputation. The lightweight gel texture absorbs quickly and works effectively to smooth fine lines around the eyes. It’s gentle enough for sensitive skin, yet powerful enough to make a visible difference. Regular use left the under-eye area looking firmer and more refreshed. Since it contains retinol, pairing it with daily SPF is essential to prevent irritation.

Among these recent empties, Dr. Dennis Gross Advanced Retinol + Ferulic Eye Serum earns the highest praise for its performance and results. The Tatcha Clay Mask offers a pleasant, pampering experience, while the Caudalie Serum shines more for its glow than its brightening power. In the end, not every luxury product needs a repurchase—but finding the ones that truly work makes the journey worth it.